Public Policy
Public Policy
  • Policymakers (e.g., members of Congress) make policy in order to please somebody
    • Their own interests
    • Interest groups (e.g., labor, business)
    • The public (e.g., public opinion)
  • Who were the president and Congress trying to please with the Affordable Care Act?
  • Six-Step Policy Process:
    Problem Identification > Agenda Setting > Formulation of Proposals >
    Legitimation of Proposals > Implementation > Evaluation
  • Evaluation: Does it work? Is society better off? This begins the process all over again!

Policy Models

Instruments of Policy

  • Government has a range of devices available:
Social Welfare Policy «
  • Catalyst: Great Depression of 1929/1930s
    • collapse of private charity, bank failures
  • John Maynard Keynes: What to do about the business cycle?
    • Traditionally, governments cut back in a depression…
      • “Victorian work ethic”
  • Keynes’ answer: Demand-side economics – create  demand
    • Prosperity: Cut back, Depression: Spend

Public Policy and Money

  • Appropriation
    • Budget proposal
    • Incrementalism (line-item budgeting)
    • Entitlements
    • Deficits
  • Our nation's growth and industrialization had consequences: Interdependence

Redistribution

  • Interdependence brings not only conflict, but also potential for harm to people through no fault of their own...
  • Techniques
    • Fiscal: Taxing & spending
    • Monetary: Credit (money) supply

Social Welfare Policy

  • Types
  • Most?* Elderly (~$1.5t), Mid. Class (~$2.2t)
  • Fewer * benefits: Poor (~$600b)
    *2015 estimates (nationalpriorities.org, based on OMB data)
  • Policies: Education, Job Train, Health, Housing
  • Economically successful, but political problematic…
  • We reward politicians for keeping taxes low and spending high all the time!
  • Result: chronic deficit spending