DIVERSITY
OF RACE, NATIONAL ORIGIN, AND ETHNICITY
By
Ann H. Tallant, International Student Advisor,
and Barry D. Friedman
North Georgia College & State University
Copyright 2003 by Ann H. Tallant and Barry D. Friedman
any Americans grow up in homogeneous
communities, where it is fairly rare to encounter a person of a different race,
national origin, or ethnic background. While
this environment creates a “comfort zone,” in which the members of the
community do not need to come to grips with “differentness” of their
neighbors, the homogeneity limits the experiences of the people in the
community. They typically
understand their own customs, values, attitudes, and even religion as essential
and inevitable, because there is no exposure to other ways of thinking about and
doing things.
This situation may be viable as long as the individual stays in that
community and as long as “others” do not migrate into the community.
Eventually, however, it is not unusual for the individual to leave the
community--for example, to go away to college or to accept employment
elsewhere—or for people of different backgrounds to migrate into the
community. At that point, the
individual faces a choice of whether to adapt to the presence of others or
whether to isolate himself with a feeling of regret that his environment is not
the way it used to be and resentment that his environment has been
“corrupted.”
The decision to seethe over the presence of others deprives a person of
an opportunity that has come along in his life:
This is the opportunity to expand the dimensions of one’s experiences,
to learn about other cultures and ways of life, and to allow one to compare and
contrast the way of life that he once considered inevitable with other
approaches to thinking and living. When
one closes off this opportunity to learn and grow, he develops, in his mind, an
“us-them” dichotomy. The
underlying assumption is that the “us” category is the superior category,
and that the “them” category is doomed to inferiority.
As an example, an American citizen may categorize as stupid an immigrant
whose command of the English language is shaky—not taking into account that
the immigrant’s command of her own native language probably compares favorably
to the American’s command of English and that the immigrant probably speaks
more languages than the American, who—if he is a typical American—probably
knows only one language. In many
similar ways, the person misjudges, based on his own limited perception of the
facts, the characteristics of other kinds of people.
It has become the policy of many institutions to embrace the notion of diversity
and to attempt to make their workforces, student bodies, etc., diverse. The rationale for encouraging diversity includes these ideas:
· Diversity
allows people to learn about the richness of the world’s cultures, ethnic
identities, and value systems.
· Diversity
prepares people to supervise,
work with, work for, do business with, teach, and serve a variety of people from
various backgrounds.
· Diversity
prepares people to work cooperatively with people of various backgrounds who
live in the same community and who, if the community is to
develop in a productive and prosperous way, will need to understand and help
each other.
· When
corporations, government agencies, and other institutions attempt to serve a
diverse community with a workforce dominated by the traditional power-holders,
these institutions often fail because of their misunderstanding of their customers and
clients. Those institutions become marginally irrelevant if they
survive at all.
· Diversity
enhances the ability of Americans to understand their government’s policies in such matters
as diplomacy, international trade, military policy, etc.
· Diversity
creates an atmosphere in which our appreciation of others’ values and beliefs
allows us to refrain from imposing our own values and beliefs on them.
The attempt to accomplish this imposition is often costly and wasteful; in international terms, for
example, it can be extremely costly in terms of the loss of goodwill.
Let’s
use North Georgia College & State University as a mini-case study.
NGCSU is committed to more diversity in its faculty and student body. NGCSU is an equal-opportunity and affirmative-action
employer, and is committed to giving complete and nondiscriminatory
consideration to applicants of various backgrounds—including candidates from
other countries—for faculty positions.
NGCSU’s Students for Social Awareness organization has been active over
the years in providing a place for discussion about the histories and
experiences of Americans of different backgrounds.
Many black civil-rights leaders and other prominent African-Americans
have been brought to the campus by the SSA.
In this manner, NGCSU students have had the opportunity to explore the
perspectives of members of American minority groups.
The study of U. S. history is dreadfully incomplete if students are
not given the chance to develop an understanding of the motivations of those in
the majority who have orchestrated discrimination against members of minority
groups as well as an understanding of the struggles waged by those who have
demanded that they be free of such discrimination.
Encouraging our students to be in the presence of those who led the black
civil-rights movement transforms the text of a chapter in a history book into a
vivid encounter with those who have brought real social change into American
life.
Determined efforts to “internationalize” NGCSU are occurring.
Some members of the faculty are brought here on H-1B visas; some others
are lawful permanent residents. Through
the University System of Georgia’s Global Partnership for International
Recruiting, NGCSU seeks to attract students from other countries. Rotary International places international students in U. S.
colleges and universities; we anticipate that four students will enroll at
NGCSU through the Rotary program during the fall semester of 2003.
The university’s Web site serves as a recruitment tool that has been
effective in attracting the interest of, and enrollment by, students from other
countries. NGCSU’s competitive
tuition and fees, which are publicized on the Web site, help to attract this
interest; frequently, international students obtain a waiver of the more
expensive out-of-state fees, another way in which NGCSU seeks to facilitate the
enrollment of students from other countries.
NGCSU’s International Student Association is a strong force for sharing
the cultures of the university’s international students.
Each year, the ISA produces an international cultural show and presents
an international festival featuring information, artifacts, and foods.
At the association’s regular meetings, members offer presentations
about their countries, sometimes including slide shows.
Many professors encourage their students to attend these events because
they provide experiences that go beyond the textbook and lecture formats of
“learning about” rather than “learning with.”
The academic standards that our
international students tend to set strengthen the overall academic and
intellectual climate of our campus. Despite
the issues of “second language,” many international students graduate with
academic honors: One cannot ignore
the intellectual feat of not only earning a college degree from an institution
whose constituents speak the “second language,” but, furthermore, of
outperforming most classmates for whom the institution’s language is native.
International students come to us not
expecting to be treated differently than anyone else—-by professors or, for
that matter, by classmates, either. For
example, an African student’s skin color may create an expectation in
classmates that he will act in ways associated with black Americans.
The classmates’ behavior will confuse the African student who has not
grown up in a black-American community, and his reaction is likely to confound
the American students. For another example, an Asian student majoring in English
literature may find herself expected to perform brilliantly in mathematics
classes, because of the stereotype that Asians are naturally adept at
quantitative analysis; it may be some time before she comes to understand why
such assumptions are being applied to her.
International students come to us with
a very different way of understanding the world and their role in the world.
Academic institutions in their countries tend to be far more regimented
and authoritarian. Also, their
standards of etiquette are markedly different from American standards.
For one example, their understanding of appropriate classroom behavior
requires that they offer a level of formal respect that is unfamiliar to
American students. For
another example, many of them have learned a different way of writing (they may
have been taught that it is rude to write persuasive rhetoric that imposes their
ideas on others and that it is preferable to write prose that is designed to
build consensus).
Because our American students have this exposure to students from other
cultures, they have access to intellectual pathways that would otherwise be
closed to them. Some of our
American students have enrolled in study-abroad programs as a direct result of
their exposure to international students, and the resulting erosion of their own
insularity. Research into
sociology, psychology, political science, criminal justice, history, and other
fields of inquiry is more informed, expansive, and productive when the student
is aware of the scope of human characteristics, attitudes, behaviors, and
experiences. Instead of writing a
survey question like, “How often do you read the Bible?”, the
researcher-in-training is more apt to write, “How often do you read the
spiritual texts of your religion?” This
enhancement of sophistication is more likely to lead to students who are
successful in graduate school, in the business sector, and in the professions,
which have been forced to come to terms with a world that is becoming smaller.
The presence of international students
on a university campus expands the world for those students who will never have
a passport. Furthermore, a diverse
presence of American citizens of various races and ethnic backgrounds enriches
the educational experience tremendously. At NGCSU, diversity has been recognized as a resource for
every member of this community. It
can contribute to other institutions and communities in the same way.
Those who are receptive to this resource stand to gain the most from the
new perspectives that will expand the boundaries of their experiences.
Personal disclaimer: This page is not a publication of North Georgia College & State University and NGCSU has not edited or examined the content of the page. The author
s of the page are solely responsible for the content.Last updated on July 28, 2004, by Barry D. Friedman.